top of page

MIDDLE OF THE ROAD

1 day ago
5 min read

TINSMAN ROAD (15)

Director: Robbie Banfitch

Screenplay: Robbie Banfitch

Starring: Robbie Banfitch, Leslie Ann Banfitch, Salem Belladonna

Running time: 119 minutes

Shudder

​

Review: RJ Bland


It's only been a matter of days since we published our review of Hunting Matthew Nichols, Markian Tarasiuk's indie found footage mockumentary about a woman trying to determine what happened to her brother, who went missing in the woods twenty years ago. And now we're posting our review of Tinsman Road, another indie found footage mockumentary about a man trying to determine what happened to his sister, who went missing in the woods three years ago. The ghost of The Blair Witch Project lives on, eh?


The 'missing person' story is unsurprisingly one of the genre's most persistent narrative angles, and it's easy to see why. It gives a protagonist a clear, urgent goal while shrouding any potential threat in absolute mystery. Films in which someone has only recently gone missing also have the added 'ticking clock' element: every passing hour reduces the chances of a positive outcome. Think films like Searching (2018), The Wicker Man (1973) and Breakdown (1998).

Then there are those more concerned with resolution than with finding the missing person alive, per se. Films like Spoorloos (1988) explore the mental anguish and obsession that can haunt someone who has never found answers about what happened to a missing loved one. It's the not knowing that's the killer. Sometimes, you just need answers, regardless of how difficult they might be to accept. Tinsman Road is neck-deep in this kind of angst.


Written, directed and starring Robbie Banfitch (who previously gave us the divisively bonkers The Outwaters), Tinsman Road follows aspiring filmmaker Robbie Lyle (Banfitch) as he returns to his family home in the backwoods of New Jersey. It's been three years since his sister Noelle mysteriously disappeared while walking along the secluded road of the title, and the family has never really recovered. Robbie's mother, Leslie (played by his real life mum Leslie Ann Banfitch), is particularly troubled by the loss and has become increasingly convinced that her daughter is still somehow present in the house. Robbie, however, isn't entirely buying the supernatural explanation. Instead, he decides to make a documentary about the family's ordeal, hoping to get to the bottom of what happened to Noelle and perhaps find some closure in the process.

Armed with his Mini-DV camera, Robbie begins documenting life in the family home, interviewing his mother and venturing into the local community to speak with people who might know something about his sister's disappearance. He also starts retracing her final movements, returning to the road where she was last seen. But between the increasingly unsettling goings-on around the house, strange occurrences involving some of Noelle's old belongings and the rather peculiar responses he receives from certain locals, Robbie begins to realise that there may be considerably more to his sister's disappearance than he initially suspected. And perhaps his mother's seemingly fanciful beliefs aren't quite so fanciful after all...


A decade or so ago, the concept of 'elevated' horror was making a significant impact on the genre. Films such as The Babadook (2014), The Witch (2015), Hereditary (2018) and Get Out (2017) all garnered critical acclaim and were perceived as somehow superior to other horror fare, thanks to their emphasis on slow-burn pacing, atmosphere, trauma and outstanding dramatic performances. A24 was a major proponent of this style of film-making. But trends have always been part of the genre; Halloween (1978) sparked a wave of slasher movies in the 80s, while Paranormal Activity did much the same for found footage in the mid-noughties. Now, we're witnessing a surge in 'liminal' horror; films that focus on transitional or empty spaces, nostalgia, ambient sound, fragmented narratives and spatial ambiguity. Skinamarink (2023), Backrooms (2026) and Exit 8 (2025) are all prime examples, but these elements have also been felt far and wide throughout the genre. While Tinsman Road doesn't immerse itself in quite as much liminality as the three titles mentioned above, its glacial pacing, passive narrator, expansive woodland setting, washed-out aesthetic, lo-fi tech and focus on a missing person (you can't get much more transitional than that!) firmly place it in the same camp. Some of it works, some of it doesn't. And, like most found-footage films, it saves the majority of its best material for the closing stages.


The first 90 minutes or so feel really do feel like one of those autumncore music videos you find on YouTube. There are lots of wintry trees, rivers, cosy home interiors, fall festivities and everyday interactions. Some will get more out of this soporific content than others. It's a vibe, for sure, but the lack of action, plot development or scares will test the patience of many (ourselves included). 'The 'horror' is largely limited to ruminations on life after death and lights that turn on and off and people sleepwalking. There's also a music box that keeps going off in the middle of the night, and by the eighth time, you're sort of sick of the bloody thing. To be fair, it's not that Tinsman Road is trying to terrify you in its first two acts. It's far more interested in building atmosphere and spending time with its characters and their grief. Which is fine, but despite Leslie Ann Banfitch's decent efforts to portray that grief, a certain tedium inevitably sets in. This isn't helped by the man behind the camera, our protagonist, being pretty insipid. His efforts to document what's happened to his missing sister feel almost apathetic. For a film that spends so much time dwelling on family grief, you never really feel much of a connection between Robbie and his sister, nor do you get much sense of the loss he's experiencing. It's all a bit too mumblecore and detached.


Thankfully, while the film largely meanders and frustrates for the first hour and a half, the final 20 minutes or so are quite excellent and add another half a star to the overall rating. Robbie heads off into the woods armed with a tent, his Mini-DV camera and a knife in search of his sister (or her remains) and ends up spending a couple of nights out there. Yes, it feels very Blair Witch, but in this instance, that's a compliment. The incremental and incidental little chills we've encountered along the way pay off big time, as Banfitch shifts up two or three gears for this final chapter. Being alone in the middle of the night in the creepy-ass woods is scary enough. Suspecting you might not be alone out there is considerably more terrifying. Chop 30 minutes off the preceding 90 and Tinsman Road would have been a far more effective film. But it is what it is. If you can persevere with the ultra-slow burn for that long, the ending might just feel worth it.









Tinsman Road is a haunting but glacially paced (and overlong) mockumentary that will test the patience of some. But the climax makes it just about a worthwhile venture.

Comments


Featured Posts
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • email
bottom of page